The Upside of Struggle

The Upside of Struggle
Dr. Renée Greenfield, Head of School Blog


The first time I heard the phrase “productive struggle” was in graduate school. I was in a math methods course, slogging through some pretty tough concepts. My professor was doing her best to encourage us, reassuring us that floundering, muddling through, and making mistakes were hardly signs of failure. In fact, in these very lurching efforts were the seeds of profound learning. 

Little did I know, more than two decades later, the notion of productive struggle would be foundational to my work, and to the work of all Carroll educators.

It’s foundational for two important reasons. 

First, underlying the concept of productive struggle is a vast reservoir of neuroscience research, demonstrating that, when kids engage in difficult but not impossible tasks, their neural pathways actually change and grow. Their brains get stronger. Advances in brain imaging technology over the last 30 years have made this exciting research possible. But well before the data emerged, this idea of neuroplasticity was—and remains—at the heart of Carroll’s mission. Through thoughtful diagnostic, prescriptive, multisensory teaching practices, we are changing how students with language-based learning differences process information and make progress.

Second, inherent in the very idea of productive struggle is that it’s different for everyone. Every student has their unique threshold—too much struggle and the task becomes discouraging; too little struggle, no gains are made; just the right amount, and motivation, progress, and confidence soar. When we say—“give each child what they most need”—this is exactly what we mean. Relying on cognitive and academic data specific to each and every student, educators identify an appropriate level of difficulty, a “Goldilocks” sweet spot. It’s an intricate dance for our skilled educators. And by centering academic experiences in this just-right zone, student outcomes are vastly improved.

Of course, lots of schools claim to champion productive struggle. Like many smart-sounding concepts, it has become a buzzword in education. But the neat thing is, at Carroll, we actually do it. 

A few examples:

  • Educators routinely explain to students why they’re tackling a task even before they dive in. This framing, and an overall emphasis on the process of learning over the end result, helps students to understand the “why” as well as the big-picture gains so they’re better prepared for the task ahead.
     
  • Carroll teachers know that generic or lavish praise isn’t helpful. Instead, they give constructive, precise, and genuine feedback, and they understand that different kids need different amounts.
     
  • Supporting productive struggle in the classroom is, admittedly, exhausting work, for educators  and students. Missteps can happen, like inadvertently assigning a too-difficult text or having to restate directions for clarity. As educators at Carroll, we view missteps as opportunities to model authentic feedback and persistence for our students. They also remind us to reflect on the process of teaching and learning

Years after my professor got me thinking differently about struggle, it’s still tough for some people to shake its negative connotation. I urge us all to think differently. Walk the halls with me at Carroll—where the needs of each and every child are carefully calibrated; where process is valued over the end result, and active, not passive learning is reinforced; where feedback is explicit and genuine so students feel supported and engaged, not disheartened. Here, the positive impact of productive struggle on learning is hard to overlook.



Recent Posts

Renee Greenfield and Maryanne Wolf Discuss the Science of Reading
Dr. Renée Greenfield, Head of School Blog

As I wrote last spring, new research exploring the neuroscience of reading has stirred the debate over how best to teach our children to read. At the forefront of the discussion is Dr. Maryanne Wolf, an internationally-known researcher, teacher, and advocate for children’s literacy, who I had the fortune of learning from as a graduate student. I recently sat down with Maryanne to get her reaction to the current dialogue around the science of reading.

The Impact of Teacher Disposition on Learning Outcomes
Dr. Renée Greenfield, Head of School Blog

In that first year of teaching at Carroll, I thought a lot about what drove their relentless optimism and persistence, neither of which are necessarily taught in teacher education programs. What leads them to work so hard for these kids? Slowly, I began to realize. The ineffable factor—the thing that really ignites learning with students—was, and is, their mindset.

Restorative Circle Practices at Carroll School
Dr. Renée Greenfield, Head of School Blog

Increasingly, restorative practices are being used in schools across the country as a powerful community-building tool. Not only do they offer an effective complement to traditional disciplinary measures, they help students to build important communication and relationship skills. At Carroll, we began exploring the use of restorative practices several years ago ... Dr. Renée shares how it's going and how it fits into Carroll's mission.

Carroll Students Speak: Jay and Stella Share about Belonging, Multis, and Wobbly Chairs
Dr. Renée Greenfield, Head of School Blog

Recently, Stella Grossman, a sixth grader, and Jay Rubenstein, a fourth grader, sat down with Renée to share their thoughts on a range of Carroll topics. Not only do their insights affirm Carroll’s mission, they remind us of the very lives and families we have the privilege of touching—even transforming. 

A Conversation with Dr. Sharon Saline on Dyslexia, ADHD, and Executive Function
Dr. Renée Greenfield, Head of School Blog

More than half of Carroll’s student population has Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) and/or executive function (EF) challenges, in addition to a language-based learning difference (LBLD). Often, it’s hard to tell which one is at play. How can parents and educators make sense of it all? Clinical psychologist Dr. Sharon Saline answers a few of Dr. Renée Greenfield's questions.

What Is My Role As a Carroll Parent?
Dr. Renée Greenfield, Head of School Blog

What is my role as a Carroll parent? What can or should I do to support my child? I’m asked this question often, particularly among families new to our community. I’m happy to provide a concrete answer.

Parent-Teacher Conferences: Critical to Student Outcomes
Dr. Renée Greenfield, Head of School Blog

At Carroll, our approach to parent-teacher conferences is purposeful and straightforward, and leads to some pretty impactful conferences and, in turn, student outcomes. Learn how conferences are designed to support students throughout the school year and beyond.

Science of Reading Orton-Gillingham Tutor
Dr. Renée Greenfield, Head of School Blog

What’s the best way to teach kids how to read? The reading debate has been simmering for decades. Recently, thanks to a newly named body of research exploring the science of reading, it has captured news headlines. Don’t get me wrong. I’m delighted by today’s energized discussion over how best to teach kids to read. It’s one of the most important conversations we can have as a nation. Here's what I'd like us to pay attention to instead.