Data Inspired Education: Could It Work in American Schools?

Data Inspired Education: Could It Work in American Schools?
  • Curriculum
  • Give Each Child
Steve Wilkins, Head of School Blog


Hmm… Let’s see. What if I were a fifth grade English Language Arts teacher? What should I teach my students this year?

My school system provides my class with plenty of textbooks with a big “Level 5” logo on the cover, and it is full of all sorts of pre-packaged lessons about grammar, vocabulary, inference making, and writing activities. But I know that isn’t enough to guide all my teaching. Therefore I am working on studying the Massachusetts Curriculum Frameworks for Grade 5, and I am reading a popular book by E.D. Hirsch called "What Your Fifth Grader Needs to Know." And finally, I will supplement my teaching with lessons that I have used before and some that my teaching colleagues shared with me.

This is the typical approach of the typical responsible American teacher - provide to the class what is expected according to the grade level of the students in the class. Many exceptionally kind and caring teachers do indeed recognize the variations within their class groups and find ways to differentiate instruction.

The core problem, however, is not the capacity of the typical American teacher. It is not the dedication, intelligence, resourcefulness, or compassion of the typical American teacher. The core problem is that very few schools provide teachers with sufficient information about the needs of each student. Therefore, they cannot address the needs of many of their students.

Most schools don’t know who they are teaching. Sure, they know the names of their students and can offer a few sentences about each of them. But most schools don’t have a deep understanding of a student’s strengths and weaknesses at the level of task analysis. They don’t have a data set on student performance nor a sense of a student’s trajectory. Most schools aren’t complex enough to address the complexities in their students.

How, then, could they possibly know what to teach them? How, then, could they know what lessons and approaches will best help a particular student?

Generally they don’t. American schools largely operate with a “50%ile Approach” to education in which students who fall slightly above or below the mean are probably getting a fairly appropriate education. Those who fall significantly above or below aren’t getting an education tailored to their needs. And those who have some skills the furthest above and furthest skills well below the mean are the hardest students to educate of all.

At Carroll, there is a numerical profile that helps define our neighborhood of learners. The incoming 100 students who are new to Carroll this fall arrive with an extensive set of evaluations that provide us with valuable data.

The mean full scale IQ for this new group of students is at the 57%ile. Within that score, their visual-spatial scores average are nearly at the 70%ile and their verbal comprehension scores at the 65%ile. The mean scores that measure reading efficiency fall at the 32%ile. The phonemic decoding scores of this group are at the 20%ile. This is definitional.

These data begin, but only begin, to tell a story of how and what to teach. Within the “typical Carroll kid” there are so many academic, cognitive, and personality differences. All these data need to be tracked. 
We know that we have smart kids who are performing well below where they should be in their reading skills. This tells us how to educate our teachers and tutors. It tells us how to structure the educational program. We have designed an entire school to deliver what each of these children most needs.

If all schools knew who they were teaching, schools would be organized very differently than they are today. We would not create vertical hierarchies of Advanced Placement classes, college prep classes, standard classes, vocational studies, basic classes, and special education. Rather, we would create a variety of class groups across a horizontal set of offerings based on data on student performance. 

Let’s see. What if I were a fifth grade English Language Arts teacher? What should I teach my students this year?

Let me go to the student data profile database. I will find out where my students are performing well and where they seem to need some targeted teaching and learning interventions. I will collect materials that will provide each student with what that student most needs. I will track each student’s progress throughout the year, adjusting my lessons day-by-day as I study a child’s trajectory. I will share evidence of progress constantly with each student. Hmmm... 

  • Curriculum
  • Education Policy

Recent Posts

Science of Reading Orton-Gillingham Tutor
Dr. Renée Greenfield, Head of School Blog

What’s the best way to teach kids how to read? The reading debate has been simmering for decades. Recently, thanks to a newly named body of research exploring the science of reading, it has captured news headlines. Don’t get me wrong. I’m delighted by today’s energized discussion over how best to teach kids to read. It’s one of the most important conversations we can have as a nation. Here's what I'd like us to pay attention to instead.

Pandemic Lessons: Carroll Learning Data Reveals Student Resilience
Dr. Renée Greenfield, Head of School Blog

Late last month, the journal Nature Human Behavior published the largest, most comprehensive, global study to date on learning progress two-and-a-half years into the pandemic. The results—based on data provided from 15 countries (excluding low-income nations)—were sobering. In short, kids worldwide experienced learning deficits equal to ⅓ of a school year. What’s more, now nearly three years out, evidence suggests those deficits still haven’t been recovered. The story for Carroll students—I’m pleased to say—is different.

9 Carroll Successes in 2022
Dr. Renée Greenfield, Head of School Blog

Every chance they get, Carroll educators celebrate student victories, big and small. By doing so, they foster joy not simply in what was accomplished, but in all the learning that is yet to come. Following their lead, and in the spirit of year-end reflection, I’ve created my own highlight reel of successes and sources of pride—in no particular order—from 2022. It feels important to pause and take stock of the tremendously meaningful work we engage in at Carroll. What’s more, writing it down has made me even more excited for all that lies ahead in 2023!

The Upside of Struggle
Dr. Renée Greenfield, Head of School Blog

The first time I heard the phrase “productive struggle” was in graduate school. I was in a math methods course, slogging through some pretty tough concepts. My professor was doing her best to encourage us, reassuring us that floundering, muddling through, and making mistakes were hardly signs of failure. In fact, in these very lurching efforts were the seeds of profound learning. Little did I know, more than two decades later, the notion of productive struggle would be foundational to my work, and to the work of all Carroll educators.

Dyslexia 1 in 5 students
Dr. Renée Greenfield, Head of School Blog

Last month, Massachusetts passed a momentous and long-awaited piece of legislation requiring schools to screen young students for dyslexia and other learning differences at least twice a year. Beginning on July 1, 2023, this right-to-read legislation will combat an entrenched wait-to-fail approach in the state’s public schools. Why should this matter to the Carroll community?

Starting a New School: All the Feels and Belonging
Dr. Renée Greenfield, Head of School Blog

As we launch the school year, it brings all the feels. And all the feels are welcome - from our students, their families, and all the committed adults that work at Carroll. As I met with new families last week, I named some of the different feelings and emotions that may accompany joining the Carroll School community.

Reopening School during a Global Pandemic
Steve Wilkins, Head of School Blog

Every family with school aged children is in a tough spot this fall. How to get back to school is nothing but a large basket full of hard decisions. In this blog, I write about what we share as a community as we look forward to Carroll School’s reopening.

GECCO: Give Each Child Carroll Online
Steve Wilkins, Head of School Blog

Carroll School declares that our job is to give each child what that child most needs. It doesn’t matter whether we are forced to social distance or whether we are in person. That is our job. A remote plan that failed to focus on this principle would never work properly for the Carroll community. Steve Wilkins shares how we approach this task.